No-Bake Nutter Butter Turkey

Turn simple ingredients into adorable Thanksgiving turkey cookies! These fun, no-bake treats are perfect for holiday gatherings and easy enough for kids to make. Thanks to Crazy Busy Mama for the inspiration! This recipe can be found in my new “Celebrate Festive Fall with Miss Annie” cookbook, available on Amazon.

Author: Lori Conway

Print

With ImageWithout Image

NO-BAKE NUTTER BUTTER TURKEY

Turn simple ingredients into adorable Thanksgiving turkey cookies! These fun, no-bake treats are perfect for holiday gatherings and easy enough for kids to make.

Cook modePrevent screen from turning off

Ingredients

• Nutter Butter Cookies
• Miniature Reese's Cup (for the turkey face)
• Vanilla frosting (for glue)
• Candy eyes
• Orange M&M's (cut in half for the beak)
• Red frosting (for the wattle)
• Candy corn (for tail feathers)

Instructions

1. Prepare the Cookies: Lay the Nutter Butter Cookies flat on a tray or parchment paper.
2. Add the Turkey Face: Place a small dollop of frosting in the lower half of the cookie. Press a miniature Reese's (bottom side down) onto the frosting.
3. Decorate the Face: Use the frosting to attach candy eyes to the Reese's Cup. Add a halved orange M&M below the eyes for the beak. Use red frosting to draw a small wattle next to the beak.
4. Attach the Tail Feathers: Using vanilla frosting as glue, arrange candy corn along the top half of the cookie to form the turkey's tail feathers.
5. Set and Serve: Allow the frosting to set for a few minutes, then enjoy your festive Nutter Butter Turkey Cookies.